Connectivity Is An Equity Issue

Any school librarian who worked through the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020 knows that access to technology and reliable internet connectivity cannot be taken for granted. When learning moved online, the disparities became impossible to ignore. Having digital resources available didn’t mean every student could use them.

Imagine assigning students a research project that requires them to use online databases, watch instructional videos, or collaborate on a shared document. Now imagine that some of those students can’t access the internet. How can we expect students to succeed when they don’t have equal access to the tools they need?

For nearly 30 years, the federal E-Rate program has helped schools and libraries afford broadband internet access. But that support is now being challenged. On November 13, the American Library Association (ALA) reported that hundreds of library supporters have spoken out in defense of E-Rate as the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) is considering proposals that could eliminate or significantly limit the program.

According to ALA, more than 600 libraries, institutions, and individuals representing at least 44 states submitted comments supporting library E-Rate funding. Their message was clear: Affordable, reliable internet access is essential to the communities libraries serve.

For school librarians, this is more than a funding issue. It’s an equity issue.

We talk frequently about providing equitable access to information. We work to build diverse collections and ensure that students can find resources that meet their learning needs. But a database subscription has little value if students can’t access it. Digital learning opportunities become limited when schools lack adequate bandwidth. And when connectivity is inconsistent, teachers may be forced to abandon instructional activities they’ve carefully planned.

These challenges don’t affect every school equally. Schools with fewer financial resources may have less flexibility to compensate for lost funding. The result could be an even wider gap between students who have access to digital learning opportunities and those who don’t.

What can school librarians do?

  • Know your school’s connectivity needs. Talk with your technology department and administrators. Is the existing network meeting instructional demands? Are there recurring problems that interfere with teaching and learning? Understanding the situation helps you advocate from an informed position.
  • Document the impact. When connectivity problems disrupt a lesson or prevent students from accessing resources, keep track of what happened. Specific examples demonstrate why reliable internet access matters more effectively than general statements about technology.
  • Make the connection to learning. Help decision-makers understand how broadband supports the school’s educational goals. Explain how students use digital resources for research and why dependable access is necessary for instruction.
  • Stay informed and speak up. Follow developments affecting E-Rate and other technology funding programs. Share relevant information with administrators and your professional associations. ALA is encouraging library advocates to contact their congressional representatives about the proposed changes. Your knowledge of how connectivity affects students can contribute to those conversations.
  • Look for immediate solutions. While larger funding decisions are being made, work with colleagues to identify ways to reduce access barriers. Could resources be downloaded for offline use? Are alternative materials available when connections fail? These measures won’t replace reliable broadband, but they can help students continue learning.

As school librarians, we understand that access to information is fundamental to education. We also know that access means more than simply having resources available. Students must be able to use them. The debate over E-Rate is a reminder that the infrastructure supporting learning cannot be taken for granted. Equitable access to information requires equitable access to the technology that delivers it.

Leading In the Age of AI

Guest Poster: Rona Gofstein

You can’t get away from it. Artificial Intelligence is everywhere both assistive and generative. Whether you are excited by its possibilities, concerned about its implications, or wishing it would simply go away, AI is changing how we find, evaluate, create, and use information. And that means it is changing our schools and our libraries.

As school librarians, what do we do about it? We lead.

That doesn’t mean you need to become an AI expert. It doesn’t mean embracing every new tool that comes along or even support it. Leadership doesn’t require you have all the answers. But it does require being willing to learn, ask questions, and participate in conversations that affect our students and our schools. And AI is definitely one of those conversations.

AASL has been providing resources to help school librarians navigate this changing landscape. In Leveraging AI in School Libraries: From Basics to Best Practices, AI in education is described as both transformative and disorienting. I suspect many of us can relate to that. But AASL also sees opportunities for school librarians to use AI to support teaching and learning and improve library services. Before you can lead others, however, you need to learn.

Explore. If you haven’t used an AI tool, try one. Ask it a question. Ask it to summarize something you already know well and see what it gets right—and wrong. Learn what terms such as “hallucination” mean in connection with AI. You don’t have to become an expert. You do need to understand the basics.

Ask questions. What AI tools are already being used in your district? Does your district have an AI or anti-AI policy? Are teachers using it? What about students? What privacy issues need to be considered? ALA’s current guidance on AI reminds libraries to consider not only usefulness, but privacy, equity, ethics, accuracy, and the continued importance of human judgment.

Connect it to what you already know. Librarians have been helping students navigate changing information environments for decades. We taught them how to search databases. Then came the internet, Google, Wikipedia, social media, and increasing concerns about misinformation.

Get into the conversation. If your school or district is discussing how AI will be used, school librarians belong at that table. We understand information literacy. We understand copyright, attribution, privacy, research, and source evaluation. We work across grade levels and subject areas. That gives us a perspective few others in the building have.

Last week, you were asked, “Do they know what you do?” Here’s another way to show them. You don’t need to walk into the room with all the answers. Walk in with good questions. Bring what you already know about information, learners, and your school community. Be willing to listen and learn.

AI will continue to change. The tools we’re discussing today may be replaced by something entirely different tomorrow. That’s why this isn’t really about mastering a particular technology. It’s about leadership. Leaders don’t wait until they know everything before they engage with change. They learn. They ask questions. They consider the risks as well as the opportunities. And then they help others find a thoughtful way forward.

Through all the technological changes, our fundamental responsibility remains the same: helping students become thoughtful, ethical, informed users and creators of information. AI doesn’t eliminate that responsibility. It makes it more important.  AI is here. Make sure school librarians are part of what comes next.